Browsing by Author "Davis, Dustin"
Now showing 1 - 11 of 11
- Results Per Page
- Sort Options
- Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsAbsorption Troughs of Lyα Emitters in HETDEX(2024)
;Weiss, Laurel H. ;Davis, Dustin ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Gazagnes, Simon ;Mirza Khanlari, Mahan ;Mentuch Cooper, Erin ;Chisholm, John ;Berg, Danielle ;Bowman, William P. ;Byrohl, ChrisZeimann, Gregory R.Abstract The Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX) is designed to detect and measure the redshifts of more than 1 million Ly α emitting galaxies (LAEs) 1.88 < z < 3.52. In addition to its cosmological measurements, these data enable studies of Ly α spectral profiles and the underlying radiative transfer. Using the roughly half a million LAEs in the HETDEX Data Release 3, we stack various subsets to obtain the typical Ly α profile for the z ∼ 2–3 epoch and to understand their physical properties. We find clear absorption wings around Ly α emission, which extend ∼2000 km s −1 both redward and blueward of the central line. Using far-UV spectra of nearby (0.002 < z < 0.182) LAEs in the COS Legacy Archive Spectroscopic Survey treasury and optical/near-IR spectra of 2.8 < z < 6.7 LAEs in the Multi Unit Spectroscopic-Wide survey, we observe absorption profiles in both redshift regimes. Dividing the sample by volume density shows that the troughs increase in higher-density regions. This trend suggests that the depth of the absorption is dependent on the local density of objects near the LAE, a geometry that is similar to damped Ly α systems. Simple simulations of Ly α radiative transfer can produce similar troughs due to absorption of light from background sources by H i gas surrounding the LAEs. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsHETDEX Public Source Catalog 1—Stacking 50,000 Lyman Alpha Emitters ∗(2023)
;Davis, Dustin ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Bowman, William P. ;Garcia Castanheira, Barbara ;Chisholm, John ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Fabricius, Maximilian ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Finkelstein, Steven L.Zeimann, GregoryAbstract We describe the ensemble properties of the 1.9 < z < 3.5 Lyman alpha emitters (LAEs) found in the HETDEX survey’s first public data release, HETDEX Public Source Catalog 1. Stacking the low-resolution ( R ∼ 800) spectra greatly increases the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N), revealing spectral features otherwise hidden by noise, and we show that the stacked spectrum is representative of an average member of the set. The flux-limited, Ly α S/N restricted stack of 50,000 HETDEX LAEs shows the ensemble biweight average z ∼ 2.6 LAE to be a blue (UV continuum slope ∼ −2.4 and E(B – V) < 0.1), moderately bright ( M UV ∼ −19.7) star-forming galaxy with strong Ly α emission (log L Ly α ∼ 42.8 and W λ (Ly α ) ∼ 114 Å), and potentially significant leakage of ionizing radiation. The rest-frame UV light is dominated by a young, metal-poor stellar population with an average age of 5–15 Myr and metallicity of 0.2–0.3 Z ⊙ . - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsHETDEX Public Source Catalog 1: 220 K Sources Including Over 50 K Lyα Emitters from an Untargeted Wide-area Spectroscopic Survey*(2023)
;Mentuch Cooper, Erin ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Davis, Dustin ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Liu, Chenxu ;Zeimann, Gregory ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Feldmeier, John J. ;Drory, Niv ;Jeong, DonghuiZhang, YechiAbstract We present the first publicly released catalog of sources obtained from the Hobby-Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX). HETDEX is an integral field spectroscopic survey designed to measure the Hubble expansion parameter and angular diameter distance at 1.88 < z < 3.52 by using the spatial distribution of more than a million Ly α -emitting galaxies over a total target area of 540 deg 2 . The catalog comes from contiguous fiber spectra coverage of 25 deg 2 of sky from 2017 January through 2020 June, where object detection is performed through two complementary detection methods: one designed to search for line emission and the other a search for continuum emission. The HETDEX public release catalog is dominated by emission-line galaxies and includes 51,863 Ly α -emitting galaxy (LAE) identifications and 123,891 [O ii ]-emitting galaxies at z < 0.5. Also included in the catalog are 37,916 stars, 5274 low-redshift ( z < 0.5) galaxies without emission lines, and 4976 active galactic nuclei. The catalog provides sky coordinates, redshifts, line identifications, classification information, line fluxes, [O ii ] and Ly α line luminosities where applicable, and spectra for all identified sources processed by the HETDEX detection pipeline. Extensive testing demonstrates that HETDEX redshifts agree to within Δ z < 0.02, 96.1% of the time to those in external spectroscopic catalogs. We measure the photometric counterpart fraction in deep ancillary Hyper Suprime-Cam imaging and find that only 55.5% of the LAE sample has an r -band continuum counterpart down to a limiting magnitude of r ∼ 26.2 mag (AB) indicating that an LAE search of similar sensitivity to HETDEX with photometric preselection would miss nearly half of the HETDEX LAE catalog sample. Data access and details about the catalog can be found online at http://hetdex.org/ . A copy of the catalogs presented in this work (Version 3.2) is available to download at Zenodo doi: 10.5281/zenodo.7448504 . - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsStellar Populations of Lyα-emitting Galaxies in the HETDEX Survey. I. An Analysis of LAEs in the GOODS-N Field(2022)
;McCarron, Adam P. ;Finkelstein, Steven L. ;Chavez Ortiz, Oscar A. ;Davis, Dustin ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Jung, Intae ;White, Delaney R. ;Leung, Gene C. K. ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Acquaviva, Viviana ;Sánchez, Ariel G. ;Bowman, William P. ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Gawiser, Eric ;Gronwall, Caryl ;Hill, Gary J.; ;Landriau, Martin ;Liu, Chenxu ;Mock, Daniel N. ;McCarron, Adam P.; ;Finkelstein, Steven L.; ;Chavez Ortiz, Oscar A.; ;Davis, Dustin; ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch; ;Jung, Intae; ;White, Delaney R.; ;Leung, Gene C. K.; ;Gebhardt, Karl; ;Acquaviva, Viviana; ;Bowman, William P.; ;Ciardullo, Robin; ;Gawiser, Eric; ;Gronwall, Caryl; ;Hill, Gary J.; ;Kollatschny, Wolfram; ;Landriau, Martin; ;Liu, Chenxu; ;Mock, Daniel N.;Sánchez, Ariel G.;Abstract We present the results of a stellar population analysis of 72 Ly α -emitting galaxies (LAEs) in GOODS-N at 1.9 < z < 3.5 spectroscopically identified by the Hobby−Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX). We provide a method for connecting emission-line detections from the blind spectroscopic survey to imaging counterparts, a crucial tool needed as HETDEX builds a massive database of ∼1 million Ly α detections. Using photometric data spanning as many as 11 filters covering 0.4 < λ ( μ m) < 4.5 from the Hubble Space Telescope and Spitzer Space Telescope, we study the objects’ global properties and explore which properties impact the strength of Ly α emission. We measure a median stellar mass of 0.8 − 0.5 + 2.9 × 10 9 M ⊙ and conclude that the physical properties of HETDEX spectroscopically selected LAEs are comparable to LAEs selected by previous deep narrowband studies. We find that stellar mass and star formation rate correlate strongly with the Ly α equivalent width. We then use a known sample of z > 7 LAEs to perform a protostudy of predicting Ly α emission from galaxies in the epoch of reionization, finding agreement at the 1 σ level between prediction and observation for the majority of strong emitters. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe Active Galactic Nuclei in the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment Survey (HETDEX). I. Sample Selection(2022-07-21)
;Liu, Chenxu ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Davis, Dustin ;Schneider, Donald P. ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Finkelstein, Steven L. ;Gronwall, Caryl ;Guo, Yuchen ;Hill, Gary J. ;House, Lindsay ;Jeong, Donghui ;Jogee, Shardha; ;Krumpe, Mirko ;Landriau, Martin ;Chavez Ortiz, Oscar A ;Zhang, Yechi ;Liu, Chenxu; ;Gebhardt, Karl; ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch; ;Davis, Dustin; ;Schneider, Donald P.; ;Ciardullo, Robin; ;Farrow, Daniel J.; ;Finkelstein, Steven L.; ;Gronwall, Caryl; ;Guo, Yuchen; ;Hill, Gary J.; ;House, Lindsay; ;Jeong, Donghui; ;Jogee, Shardha; ;Kollatschny, Wolfram; ;Krumpe, Mirko; ;Landriau, Martin; ;Chavez Ortiz, Oscar A;Zhang, Yechi;We present the first active galactic nuclei (AGN) catalog of the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment Survey (HETDEX) observed between 2017 January and 2020 June. HETDEX is an ongoing spectroscopic survey (3500–5500 Å) with no target preselection based on magnitudes, colors or morphologies, enabling us to select AGN based solely on their spectral features. Both luminous quasars and low-luminosity Seyferts are found in our catalog. AGN candidates are selected with at least two significant AGN emission lines, such as the Lyα and C iv λ1549 line pair, or with a single broad emission line with FWHM > 1000 km s−1. Each source is further confirmed by visual inspections. This catalog contains 5322 AGN, covering an effective sky coverage of 30.61 deg2. A total of 3733 of these AGN have secure redshifts, and we provide redshift estimates for the remaining 1589 single broad-line AGN with no crossmatched spectral redshifts from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 14 of QSOs. The redshift range of the AGN catalog is 0.25 < z < 4.32, with a median of z = 2.1. The bolometric luminosity range is 109–1014 L ☉ with a median of 1012 L ☉. The median r-band magnitude of our AGN catalog is 21.6 mag, with 34% having r > 22.5, and 2.6% reaching the detection limit at r ∼ 26 mag of the deepest imaging surveys we searched. We also provide a composite spectrum of the AGN sample covering 700–4400 Å. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe Active Galactic Nuclei in the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment Survey (HETDEX). II. Luminosity Function(2022-08-23)
;Liu, Chenxu ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Zhang, Yechi ;Schneider, Donald P. ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Davis, Dustin ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Finkelstein, Steven L. ;Gronwall, Caryl ;Hill, Gary J. ;House, Lindsay ;Jeong, Donghui; ;Niemeyer, Maja Lujan ;Tuttle, Sarah ;Liu, Chenxu; ;Gebhardt, Karl; ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch; ;Zhang, Yechi; ;Schneider, Donald P.; ;Ciardullo, Robin; ;Davis, Dustin; ;Farrow, Daniel J.; ;Finkelstein, Steven L.; ;Gronwall, Caryl; ;Hill, Gary J.; ;House, Lindsay; ;Jeong, Donghui; ;Kollatschny, Wolfram; ;Niemeyer, Maja Lujan;Tuttle, Sarah;AbstractWe present the Lyα emission line luminosity function (LF) of the active galactic nuclei (AGN) in the first release of the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment Survey (HETDEX) AGN catalog. The AGN are selected either by emission line pairs characteristic of AGN or by a single broad emission line, free of any photometric preselections (magnitude/color/morphology). The sample consists of 2346 AGN spanning 1.88 < z < 3.53, covering an effective area of 30.61 deg2. Approximately 2.6% of the HETDEX AGN are not detected at >5σ confidence at r ∼ 26 in the deepest r-band images we have searched. The Lyα line luminosity ranges from ∼1042.3 to 1045.9 erg s−1. Our Lyα LF shows a turnover luminosity with opposite slopes on the bright end and the faint end: The space density is highest at LLyα∗=1043.4 erg s−1. We explore the evolution of the AGN LF over a broader redshift range (0.8 < z < 3); constructing the rest-frame ultraviolet (UV) LF with the 1450 Å monochromatic luminosity of the power-law component of the continuum (M1450) from M 1450 ∼ −18 to −27.5. We divide the sample into three redshift bins (z ∼ 1.5, 2.1, and 2.6). In all three redshift bins, our UV LFs indicate that the space density of AGN is highest at the turnover luminosity M1450* with opposite slopes on the bright end and the faint end. The M 1450 LFs in the three redshift bins can be well fit with a luminosity evolution and density evolution model: the turnover luminosity ( M1450* ) increases, and the turnover density (Φ*) decreases with increasing redshift. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe Active Galactic Nuclei in the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment Survey (HETDEX). III. A Red Quasar with Extremely High Equivalent Widths Showing Powerful Outflows(2022-11-18)
;Gebhardt, Karl; ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Davis, Dustin ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Finkelstein, Steven L. ;Gawiser, Eric ;Gronwall, Caryl ;Hill, Gary J. ;House, Lindsay ;Schneider, Donald P. ;Urrutia, Tanya ;Zeimann, Gregory R. ;Liu, Chenxu; ;Gebhardt, Karl; ;Kollatschny, Wolfram; ;Ciardullo, Robin; ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch; ;Davis, Dustin; ;Farrow, Daniel J.; ;Finkelstein, Steven L.; ;Gawiser, Eric; ;Gronwall, Caryl; ;Hill, Gary J.; ;House, Lindsay; ;Schneider, Donald P.; ;Urrutia, Tanya;Zeimann, Gregory R.;AbstractWe report an active galactic nucleus (AGN) with an extremely high equivalent width (EW), EWLyα+N V,rest ≳921 Å, in the rest frame, at z ∼ 2.24 in the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment Survey (HETDEX), as a representative case of the high-EW AGN population. The continuum level is a nondetection in the HETDEX spectrum; thus the measured EW is a lower limit. The source is detected with significant emission lines (>7σ) at Lyα + N v λ1241, C iv λ1549, and a moderate emission line (∼4σ) at He ii λ1640 within the wavelength coverage of HETDEX (3500–5500 Å). The r-band magnitude is 24.57 from the Hyper Suprime-Cam-HETDEX joint survey with a detection limit of r = 25.12 at 5σ. The Lyα emission line spans a clearly resolved region of ∼10″ (85 kpc) in diameter. The Lyα line profile is strongly double peaked. The spectral decomposed blue gas and red gas Lyα emission are separated by ∼1.″2 (10.1 kpc) with a line-of-sight velocity offset of ∼1100 km s−1. This source is probably an obscured AGN with powerful winds. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe HETDEX Survey Emission-line Exploration and Source Classification*(2023)
;Davis, Dustin ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Fabricius, Maximilian ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Feldmeier, John J. ;Finkelstein, Steven L. ;Gawiser, Eric ;Gronwall, CarylZhang, YechiAbstract The Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX) is an untargeted spectroscopic survey that aims to measure the expansion rate of the universe at z ∼ 2.4 to 1% precision for both H ( z ) and D A ( z ). HETDEX is in the process of mapping in excess of one million Ly α emitting (LAE) galaxies and a similar number of lower- z galaxies as a tracer of the large-scale structure. The success of the measurement is predicated on the post-observation separation of galaxies with Ly α emission from the lower- z interloping galaxies, primarily [O ii ], with low contamination and high recovery rates. The Emission Line eXplorer (ELiXer) is the principal classification tool for HETDEX, providing a tunable balance between contamination and completeness as dictated by science needs. By combining multiple selection criteria, ELiXer improves upon the 20 Å rest-frame equivalent width cut commonly used to distinguish LAEs from lower- z [O ii ] emitting galaxies. Despite a spectral resolving power, R ∼ 800, that cannot resolve the [O ii ] doublet, we demonstrate the ability to distinguish LAEs from foreground galaxies with 98.1% accuracy. We estimate a contamination rate of Ly α by [O ii ] of 1.2% and a Ly α recovery rate of 99.1% using the default ELiXer configuration. These rates meet the HETDEX science requirements. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX) Survey Design, Reductions, and Detections(The American Astronomical Society, 2021)
;Gebhardt, Karl ;Mentuch Cooper, Erin ;Ciardullo, Robin ;Acquaviva, Viviana ;Bender, Ralf ;Bowman, William P. ;Castanheira, Barbara G. ;Dalton, Gavin ;Davis, Dustin ;de Jong, Roelof S. ;Zhang, Yechi; ;Gebhardt, Karl; ;Mentuch Cooper, Erin; ;Ciardullo, Robin; ;Acquaviva, Viviana; ;Bender, Ralf; ;Bowman, William P.; ;Castanheira, Barbara G.; ;Dalton, Gavin; ;Davis, Dustin; ;de Jong, Roelof S.; ;DePoy, D. L.; ;Devarakonda, Yaswant; ;Dongsheng, Sun; ;Drory, Niv; ;Fabricius, Maximilian; ;Farrow, Daniel J.; ;Feldmeier, John; ;Finkelstein, Steven L.; ;Froning, Cynthia S.; ;Gawiser, Eric; ;Gronwall, Caryl; ;Herold, Laura; ;Hill, Gary J.; ;Hopp, Ulrich; ;House, Lindsay R.; ;Janowiecki, Steven; ;Jarvis, Matthew; ;Jeong, Donghui; ;Jogee, Shardha; ;Kakuma, Ryota; ;Kelz, Andreas; ;Kollatschny, W.; ;Komatsu, Eiichiro; ;Krumpe, Mirko; ;Landriau, Martin; ;Liu, Chenxu; ;Niemeyer, Maja Lujan; ;MacQueen, Phillip; ;Marshall, Jennifer; ;Mawatari, Ken; ;McLinden, Emily M.; ;Mukae, Shiro; ;Nagaraj, Gautam; ;Ono, Yoshiaki; ;Ouchi, Masami; ;Papovich, Casey; ;Sakai, Nao; ;Saito, Shun; ;Schneider, Donald P.; ;Schulze, Andreas; ;Shanmugasundararaj, Khavvia; ;Shetrone, Matthew; ;Sneden, Chris; ;Snigula, Jan; ;Steinmetz, Matthias; ;Thomas, Benjamin P.; ;Thomas, Brianna; ;Tuttle, Sarah; ;Urrutia, Tanya; ;Wisotzki, Lutz; ;Wold, Isak; ;Zeimann, Gregory;Zhang, Yechi;Abstract We describe the survey design, calibration, commissioning, and emission-line detection algorithms for the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX). The goal of HETDEX is to measure the redshifts of over a million Ly α emitting galaxies between 1.88 < z < 3.52, in a 540 deg 2 area encompassing a comoving volume of 10.9 Gpc 3 . No preselection of targets is involved; instead the HETDEX measurements are accomplished via a spectroscopic survey using a suite of wide-field integral field units distributed over the focal plane of the telescope. This survey measures the Hubble expansion parameter and angular diameter distance, with a final expected accuracy of better than 1%. We detail the project’s observational strategy, reduction pipeline, source detection, and catalog generation, and present initial results for science verification in the Cosmological Evolution Survey, Extended Groth Strip, and Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey North fields. We demonstrate that our data reach the required specifications in throughput, astrometric accuracy, flux limit, and object detection, with the end products being a catalog of emission-line sources, their object classifications, and flux-calibrated spectra. - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe Preexplosion Environments and the Progenitor of SN 2023ixf from the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX)(2023)
;Liu, Chenxu ;Chen, Xinlei ;Er, Xinzhong ;Zeimann, Gregory R. ;Vinkó, József ;Wheeler, J. Craig ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Davis, Dustin ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Gebhardt, KarlLiu, XiaoweiAbstract Supernova (SN) 2023ixf was discovered on 2023 May 19. The host galaxy, M101, was observed by the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment collaboration over the period 2020 April 30–2020 July 10, using the Visible Integral-field Replicable Unit Spectrograph (3470 ≲ λ ≲ 5540 Å) on the 10 m Hobby–Eberly Telescope. The fiber filling factor within ±30″ of SN 2023ixf is 80% with a spatial resolution of 1″. The r < 5.″5 surroundings are 100% covered. This allows us to analyze the spatially resolved preexplosion local environments of SN 2023ixf with nebular emission lines. The two-dimensional maps of the extinction and the star formation rate (SFR) surface density (Σ SFR ) show weak increasing trends in the radial distributions within the r < 5.″5 regions, suggesting lower values of extinction and SFR in the vicinity of the progenitor of SN 2023ixf. The median extinction and that of the surface density of SFR within r < 3″ are E ( B − V ) = 0.06 ± 0.14, and Σ SFR = 10 − 5.44 ± 0.66 M ☉ yr − 1 arcsec − 2 . There is no significant change in extinction before and after the explosion. The gas metallicity does not change significantly with the separation from SN 2023ixf. The metal-rich branch of the R 23 calculations indicates that the gas metallicity around SN 2023ixf is similar to the solar metallicity (∼ Z ☉ ). The archival deep images from the Canada–France–Hawaii Telescope Legacy Survey (CFHTLS) show a clear detection of the progenitor of SN 2023ixf in the z band at 22.778 ± 0.063 mag, but nondetections in the remaining four bands of CFHTLS ( u , g , r , i ). The results suggest a massive progenitor of ≈22 M ☉ . - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settingsThe Stellar Mass–Black Hole Mass Relation at z ∼ 2 down to BH∼107M⊙ Determined by HETDEX(2023)
;Zhang, Yechi ;Ouchi, Masami ;Gebhardt, Karl ;Liu, Chenxu ;Harikane, Yuichi ;Cooper, Erin Mentuch ;Davis, Dustin ;Farrow, Daniel J. ;Gawiser, Eric ;Hill, Gary J.Krumpe, MirkoAbstract We investigate the stellar mass–black hole mass ( * – BH ) relation with type 1 active galactic nuclei (AGNs) down to BH = 10 7 M ⊙ , corresponding to a ≃ −21 absolute magnitude in rest-frame ultraviolet, at z = 2–2.5. Exploiting the deep and large-area spectroscopic survey of the Hobby–Eberly Telescope Dark Energy Experiment (HETDEX), we identify 66 type 1 AGNs with BH ranging from 10 7 –10 10 M ⊙ that are measured with single-epoch virial method using C iv emission lines detected in the HETDEX spectra. * of the host galaxies are estimated from optical to near-infrared photometric data taken with Spitzer, the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer, and ground-based 4–8 m class telescopes by CIGALE spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting. We further assess the validity of SED fitting in two cases by host-nuclear decomposition performed through surface brightness profile fitting on spatially resolved host galaxies with the James Webb Space Telescope/NIRCam CEERS data. We obtain the * – BH relation covering the unexplored low-mass ranges of BH ∼ 10 7 – 10 8 M ⊙ , and conduct forward modeling to fully account for the selection biases and observational uncertainties. The intrinsic * – BH relation at z ∼ 2 has a moderate positive offset of 0.52 ± 0.14 dex from the local relation, suggestive of more efficient black hole growth at higher redshift even in the low-mass regime of BH ∼ 10 7 – 10 8 M ⊙ . Our * – BH relation is inconsistent with the BH suppression at the low- * regime predicted by recent hydrodynamic simulations at a 98% confidence level, suggesting that feedback in the low-mass systems may be weaker than those produced in hydrodynamic simulations.